As a freshman, she was named to the Gulf South Conference All-Tournament Team, scored one goal and provided three assists.

[1] As a junior, Reilly scored nine goals during the 2015 season, including seven game winners that ranked second in the Gulf South Conference (GSC).

[1] Reilly signed with Hibernian ahead of the 2018 Scottish Women's Premier League season.

[5] On 13 September 2019, Reilly signed with Bristol City for the 2019–20 FA WSL season.

[8][9] On 21 December 2019, Reilly announced her return to the SWPL, signing an 18-month contract with Rangers ahead of the 2020 season.