[2][3][4] Having been brought up through the Everton youth ranks, Levell made her debut for the first team during the 2015 FA WSL season at the age of 18.
Levell was the starting keeper during the 2017 Spring Series, playing all 9 games and conceding 7 goals as Everton won the WSL 2 title.
Following promotion, Everton signed Lizzie Durack to add competition to the goalkeeper group, limiting Levell's minutes.
Levell selected the shirt number 28, in memory of her late brother, who died on that date in September 2015.
[6] Levell was part of the Leicester City squad that won the 2020/21 FA Women's Championship.