Her other film roles include Proxy (2013), Neil Marshall's Hellboy (2019), and Two Witches (2021), which she also co-wrote.

[2] Klebe went to high school in New York City and graduated from Dartmouth College in 2001[3][4] cum laude with a major in politics and a minor in theater and film.

[citation needed] She gave up being a competitive equestrian for a more complete immersion in theater in her teens.

Klebe had a leading role in the 2021 horror film Two Witches, which she co-wrote with director Pierre Tsigaridis.

In 2024, she served as a jury member of the Compétition Cheval Noir award ceremony at the 28th Fantasia International Film Festival.