[2][3] She is the sister of Max Aaron—the 2013 U.S. champion in men's singles—and Molly Aaron, a pair skater.
[2] Competing with Craig Norris, she placed fifth on the novice level at the Pacific Coast Sectionals in the 2009–10 season.
After Settlage developed a lower back injury, in August 2015,[8] the pair missed about three months of training.
[9] The pair decided to withdraw from their Grand Prix event, the 2015 Cup of China,[8] and returned to competition at the 2015 CS Tallinn Trophy, where they placed fifth.
Interviewed in late June 2016, Aaron/Settlage said that they planned to use a revised version of their 2015–16 short program and Scheherazade for their free skate.