Al-Otaibi started playing football at the age of six while studying in Cedar City, before returning to Saudi Arabia to play with Al Yamamah FC in the 2022/23 season of the Saudi Women's Premier League.

[2] In August 2023, Al-Otaibi was sent to IMG Academy in the United States by the Saudi Arabian Football Federation as part of their project to invest in our young talents and empower a generation to create future achievements in Saudi sports.

[3] On September 28, 2024, Al-Otaibi succeeded in assist for Ghanaian striker Mavis Owusu, as her team Al Hilal defeated Eastern Flames (4-0) in the Saudi Women's Premier League.

[5] In February 2023, Al-Otaibi was selected for the inaugural under-17 team to face Kuwait in double friendly matches.

[6] In March 2023, with the under-20 team, head coach Pauline Hamill selected Al-Otaibi to play against Mauritania in double friendly matches, achieving their first international victory (3–0) in Jeddah.