As a junior player she won the girls' singles title at the Australian Championships in 1951 and 1952.

[1][2] Reitano won the singles title at the 1956 Australian Championships, defeating Thelma Long in the final in three sets after surviving a match point in the third set.

[3] At the 1959 Australian Championships Reitano won her second singles title after a straight-sets victory in the final against Renée Schuurman.

She teamed up with Margaret Court to win the women's doubles title there in 1961.

Reitano teamed up with three different partners to be the runner-up in women's doubles at the 1956, 1959, and 1962 Australian Championships.