The final remake for Windows and Macintosh was published 1998 is Reader Rabbit's Math Ages 4-6, with a personalized version released in 1999.

Upon the release of the Deluxe edition, Bill Dinsmore, The Learning Company president and chief executive officer, said: "With the release of Reader Rabbit 1 and Math Rabbit for Windows, we now offer five Windows educational software products that help to develop important learning skills".

[7] FOGG praised the easy-to-use gaming interface,[1] and The Washington Post said it is "entertaining"[8] while incorporating valuable lessons into "colorfully fun graphics".

[10] Don Crabb, writing for the Chicago Sun-Times, recommended the "outstanding"[11] software for the 1989 holiday season[12] and noted it was among the "high-quality educational software sold",[13] and that it was one of the best educational releases for offering a "solid instructional model" for teaching kids the fundamentals of mathematics[14] through "smoothly" integrating the gaming and learning[15] without "bogging them down in mindless mathematical trivia",[16] such as by teaching geometry at a very early age.

[17] Computer Shopper said the product was "remarkably good software",[18] and positively compared its depth and carde gameplay to Power Rangers ZEO PowerActive.