[4] Broadway appearances by Follette included roles in Fiddle-dee-dee (1900–1901),[5] The Prima Donna (1901), The Strollers (1901),[6] The Sleeping Beauty and the Beast (1901–1902), The Supper Club (1901–1902),[5] Twirly Whirly (1902),[5] The Wild Rose (1902),[7][8] The Big Little Princess (1903), Winsome Winnie (1903–1904),[9] Princess Beggar (1906),[10] and From Across the Pond (1907).

[11]Follette was known for an extravagant social life; she once took a train from Chicago to New York with two young businessmen, to have a lobster dinner.

[15][16] She was sought[17] to assist the prosecution at the highly-publicized trial[18] of Nesbit's husband, Harry Kendall Thaw, in 1907.

[19] "It is believed she knows more of Stanford White and the inner life and workings of Evelyn Thaw than any living person," reported one account.

[24] A showgirl character in the 1915 silent film Betty in Search of a Thrill is named "Maizie Follette".