Baltzell graduated from Mountain View High School where she played softball, basketball and volleyball.
She began her Longwood Lancers career by tying the school season record for walks and leading the team in eight offensive categories as a freshman.
[3][4] Baltzell was the first in school history to merit the NFCA honor as she broke and set surviving school records with career best in RBIs and home runs; both led and were the top conference season records, of which the home run mark still lasts.
In the conference, Baltzell too set the walks mark and led for the year in average, slugging and on base percentage.
[5] On March 1, 2014, Baltzell achieved a career high 4 hits vs. the Indiana Hoosiers, she would go on to match it again later that year.
[5] On opening day, February 6, 2015, she hit her 50th career home run off Tara Tursellino of the Delaware State Hornets.
[14] Later on April 4, she would collect her 200th career RBI vs. the Campbell Fighting Camels; connecting for a game-winning, three-run homer to do it.