Bullitt starred at Naaman Forest High School in Garland, Texas, where he was team MVP as a senior after totaling 78 tackles (43 solo), five pass deflections, and three interceptions.

In the 2006 season, as a senior outside linebacker, he started in all 13 games had 84 tackles (26 solo), one interception, one fumble recovery, and eight pass deflections.

He also saw action on defense in Week 9 against the New England as a replacement for injured Pro Bowl safety Bob Sanders.

He had his most extensive playing time in Week 17 against Tennessee, when he entered the game in the second half after the Colts rested starters on both sides of the ball.

In the 31–27 comeback win over the Texans on October 5, he intercepted a pass by quarterback Sage Rosenfels at the Indianapolis 22, with 42 seconds remaining in the game.

In the same game, however, he missed a tackle near the line of scrimmage on running back Steve Slaton, who ran 71 yards for a touchdown.

[9] After the season, Bullitt received recognition from USA Today, which listed him on its annual "All-Joe" team.

Bullitt forced a fumble and also prevented an airborne player from scoring a touchdown at the goal line.

Following his retirement, Bullitt was named coach of the Legends Football League's Dallas Desire for the franchise's return in 2016.

[22] Once Rhodes returned to the Colts prior to the 2008 season, he tried to get the number back and even offered Bullitt serious money for it, but to no avail.