[1] By 2013, the high school's enrollment had hit 900 and was declining, as Avalon, Dennis Township, and Stone Harbor were sending fewer students.

The first group of 15 ninth graders from Woodbine to be sent to Middle Township High School began attending in fall 2013.

[8] Lynda Anderson-Towns, superintendent of the Woodbine district, cited the closer proximity and smaller size of Middle Township High.

[13] The Middle Township High School Panthers[2] compete in the National Division of the Cape-Atlantic League, an athletic conference comprised of parochial and public high schools located in Atlantic, Cape May, Cumberland and Gloucester counties, that operates under the aegis of the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association (NJSIAA).

[19] LaMarr Greer had a triple-double to lead the 1993 team to the Group II title with an 81–59 victory against Hillside in the championship game played at the Rutgers Athletic Center.

[26][27] The girls tennis team won the Group III state championship in 1996, defeating Ramapo High School 3–2 in the tournament final.

Karen Biederman, an art teacher, established the project in 2018 with the Artists in Education (AIE) Residency Program contributing $10,000 in grant money.

[35] Middle Township continues to participate in the Vincent J. Appruzesse New Jersey High School Mock Trial Competition.