"[2] Caitlin Lassiter rated it three and a half stars in New Release Today, writing, "Lyrically, Mighty is a strong and worshipful effort, but sonically, things often fall short of expectation.

"[6] Giving a rating of 3.7 out of five at Christian Music Review, Laura Chambers' view was that "Every song resonates with a calm, assured mood, underscoring the peace we can experience if we trust Him in all things.

"[4] Calvin Moore, awarding the album four stars in The Christian Manifesto, says, "Mighty is an excellent live worship experience featuring evocative songs, strong music, and powerful vocals.

"[3] Giving the album four and a half stars at New Release Today, Kevin Davis states, "These excellent songs are all prayers, adorations and declarations about our great God, who is mighty to save.

"[7] Amanda Furbeck gave a three and a half star review for Worship Leader, stating, "Mighty showcases Kristene DiMarco’s talents as a singer/songwriter with 11 original songs interspersed with the familiar strains of a few traditional hymns.