The early 1990s brought the winning tradition back to Monmouth with a Jersey Cup championship and a return to Division I rugby.

Since 1994, the club has shown its resilience by winning three of four second side Jersey Cup championships and has appeared in the National playoff picture 5 times in the past 10 years.

The prospect of the Super League and competing against a larger population base brought them back to Division II.

Monmouth started the Fall 2010 season by winning their own invitational tournament, beating Princeton Athletic Club in the Final.

Note: caps and participation are accurate as of 23 April 2007 Rob Morello - best scrum half in the union, as well as 2001 Region 6 Wrestling Champion, 135 lbs.