The original co-hosts were San Diego comedians Jordan Coburn and Jaleesa Johnson; the latter has since left the show due to a pay dispute.

[2][failed verification][3] The three hosts of the show at its inception were Allison Gill (pseudonymously referred to as "A.G."), Jaleesa Johnson, and Jordan Coburn.

These include "Just the Facts", in which Gill recaps and discusses news related to the Special Counsel inquiry and Trump-Russia relations;[2][6] "Hot Notes", in which Johnson and Coburn do research about Trump and present for discussion their findings;[6] and "Fantasy Indictment League", in which the hosts and listeners speculate about the people who may be indicted in the investigation.

[8] Seth Abramson, in an opinion piece for The Guardian, has described Mueller, She Wrote as "an indispensable source of curatorial journalism for many Trump-Russia watchers".

[10] Gill said that after Barr had provided his summary, the show received abuse: "We got a lot of responses, tweets and messages [laughing and saying] mud on your face?