My First Time is an off-Broadway play that opened on July 12, 2007 at New World Stages and ran until January 22, 2010.

The show is based on a website started by Peter Foldy and Craig Stuart that grew in popularity in 1998.

He’s running the show just three nights a week and doing all the advertising, marketing and group ticket sales out of his production office.

"[4] The show opened at New World Stages in 2007 and its original cast consisted of Bill Dawes, Josh Heine, Kathy Searle and Cydnee Welburn.

There have since been productions in Korea, Mexico, Spain, Poland, Australia and all over the United States.