In 2006, Nights Like These released their debut, The Faithless, to overall positive reviews on Victory Records.
They released their most recent album Sunlight at Secondhand on October 16, 2007, again on Victory Records.
On July 15, 2008, Nights Like These posted a Myspace blog confirming their split with Victory and their new drummer Todd Pasterniak.
It was announced on October 5, 2009, on Myspace that members of Nights Like These were working on a new musical endeavor under the name Panther Piss.
As of 2013, the band is back together, playing a variety of shows in their hometown of Memphis.