[9][10][11] Austin Jones of Paste described the three tracks as "energetic, dubby, with intense, ballroom vocals that twist and contort around candy-coated basslines",[12] while The Vinyl Factory's Emily Hill said that the songs give feelings of "overwhelming sense of joy and freedom" due to their captivating hooks.

[13] Jordan Rothlein of Resident Advisor wrote that "Nothing More to Say" contains a 1986-like electro bassline and "reverb-y vocal", though its precision makes it feel "far from retro".

[6] "Nothing More to Say" was featured as one of Sophie's most essential songs in the lists published by The Fader[8] and Junkee;[13] writing for The Fader, Shaad D'Souza said: "Propulsive and gorgeous, it's one of Sophie's most straightforward songs and one of the best, showcasing in early, almost rudimentary ways, the producer's interest in repetitive, durable hooks and burbling synth sounds".

[12] On 7 December 2021, Huntleys + Palmers CEO Andrew Thomson announced that "Nothing More to Say" would be reissued in early 2022, with the funds going towards the Scottish Trans Alliance.

Thomson said that prices for the single increased drastically following Sophie's death, and he felt it was important to make more affordable copies of it.

[17] In June 2022, The Vinyl Factory named it one of the best reissues of the year until then, with Emily Hill writing that "it's the kind of feel good music you need in your life—forever and always".