It was located in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Fort Worth.

The original school, which stood on the corner of Holliday and Ninth Streets, was the center of Catholic education in North Central Texas, being the only Catholic school from Fort Worth, 114 miles to the southeast, to Clarendon, 118 miles to the northwest.

Nate Blakeslee of Texas Monthly stated that as Michael Fors Olson began his term as bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Fort Worth, Notre Dame "had suffered waning attendance and was in need of major repairs.

"[1] After experiencing years of falling enrollment, the cost of deferred maintenance, and a negative balance sheet which forced "Notre Dame to spend virtually all its $581,772 in savings that were on hand at the beginning of the 2014 school year and to borrow approximately $815,000 from the Diocese to cover many of its operational expenses," in March 2021 the Diocese of Fort Worth announced that the school would be shut down at the end of the school year.

[1] Additionally, some area parents criticized the closure in Wichita Falls-area media outlets.