After its closure, Westchester Mall was converted into Providence Place which includes First Wesleyan Church and several businesses.

The mall lost much of its traffic to retail centers in Greensboro and Winston-Salem in addition to facing challenges from the economic downturn.

[4] Steve & Barry's, which was originally Goody's Family Clothing, went out of business and was replaced by a Sears call center.

Belk left Oak Hollow in 2014 for a newer store at the Palladium shopping complex, located 5 miles (8 km) away.

[7] In January 2017, High Point University stated that it would be shutting down the mall, which at the time had 11 remaining stores, on March 10, 2017.