The first church in Stalling Busk was built in 1603, but it fell into ruin during the English Civil War.
The church originally had a low roof of stone slates, and a wooden bellcote at the west end, with a single bell.
A south porch was added at a later date, with stone benches inside.
The northern east window may have been relocated from an earlier building.
[2][3] In 1909, the new St Matthew's Church, Stalling Busk was completed.