Matt Conner, giving the album three stars from CCM Magazine, describes, "One Love Revolution loads the musical guns once again with surefire live hits...Overall, Pillar trods familiar ground on One Love Revolution, but there's no reason to miss with such a winning formula.

"[1] Awarding the album four stars for Jesus Freak Hideout, Christopher Smith writes, "it has a certain timeless quality about it.

"[4] Kevin Hoskins, giving the album four stars at Jesus Freak Hideout, states, "There are some solid ballad types found here".

"[6] Michael Weaver, indicating in a three and a half star review for Jesus Freak Hideout, mentioning, "One Love Revolution shouldn't necessarily be considered a triumphant return, but it is most definitely a solid one.

"[7] Signaling in a four and a half out of five review at Christian Music Review, Abby Baracskai, recognizes, "One Love Revolution is a great comeback album that includes touches of new things, musically and lyrically, but is everything you could want in an album to help strengthen your faith and be able to head bang and rock out to.