Keeler moved on to play with Old Blue RFC of the Rugby Super League, reaching the playoffs four times including two RSL semifinals.
Keeler served as the director of rugby and head coach of San Francisco Golden Gate RFC from 2008 to 2012.
[3] In In 2008 he led SFGG to a playoff berth, losing a close match in the quarterfinals to eventual champions the New York Athletic Club.
In the playoffs, the club routed the Dallas Harlequins in the quarterfinals, notched an injury-time win over the Denver Barbarians in the semifinals, and won its first championship by defeating Life 23–13 in the RSL final.
[6] Keeler applied for the vacant head coach position of the United States national rugby union team in 2012, but the post was given to Mike Tolkin.