McQuistan was also a member of the Jacksonville Jaguars, Cleveland Browns, and Seattle Seahawks.

He played college football at Weber State University in Utah, and was selected in the third round (69th overall) by the Raiders in the 2006 NFL draft.

[2][3] His twin brother, Pat McQuistan also played at Weber State and was selected in the seventh round (211th overall) by the Dallas Cowboys.

McQuistan was named the starting right guard for the Oakland Raiders prior to the 2006 NFL season.

He only played one game in 2008 before suffering an injury and being placed on injured reserve, thus ending his season.