The two roads cross a former alignment of the Ontario and Western Railroad before merging just north of Poyntelle.

[2][4] After Cribbs Road, PA 370 turns northward, entering Lakewood in dense woods.

After entering the Tamarack Swamp and passing a local pond, PA 370 makes a gradual curve to the east at an intersection with Dixie Highway.

The route remains rural, paralleling the Ontario and Western Railroad alignment into the hamlet of Tallmanville.

At the intersection with Como Road, PA 370 turns to the northeast, paralleling the railroad alignment into the hamlet of Preston Park.

After passing a pond, the highway leaves Starlight and continues northeastward in dense forestry.

A short while later, the route turns northward and weaves to an intersection with PA 191 (the Hancock Highway) in Buckingham Township.