Charles Terry Collins, Plymouth also formed Olivet Mission to work as an outreach in the Czech community.

[4] The Plymouth Church congregation disbanded in 1913 due to a loss of members and a lack of money.

[5] The planning of Shaker Heights by the Van Sweringen Brothers provided for land for five churches.

The cornerstone for the present church was laid on June 27, 1920, and worship began in the sanctuary on February 11, 1923.

The structure, designed by architect Charles S. Schneider, is considered one of the best examples of the Georgian Colonial style in the region.