[2] While the appearance of a pumpkinseed x bluegill sunfish can vary between individuals, they usually share a combination of traits from both parent species.

The main body color is often a combination green and light blue.

The opercular flap has a black spot on it with and orange rim running along its edge.

The face of pumpkingills have faded and less prominent blue streaking on its head compared to its pumpkinseed parent.

[2] These hybrids have been found mostly in the North Eastern and great lakes region of the United States.