The original building was built in 1892 by the Spanish government and was rebuilt in 1922 by the United States Coast Guard.

According to the Historic American Engineering Record, "Its Mediterranean appearance came from an elaborate combination of exposed and indented brick work in the facades—around doors and windows—and corners.

"[4] The "castle" look was further emphasized by reddish stucco imitating stone-work on all facades and the very elaborate exposed brick cornice topped by a parapet built in lace-like brick-work.

The lighthouse was severely damaged by the 1918 earthquake that struck the west part of the island.

The town of Rincón built El Faro Park around the lighthouse, a popular spot for surfing and whale watching.