[7] She won the inaugural women's Cadel Evans Great Ocean Road Race in January 2015.

[10][11] In late 2007, Neylan was accepted onto the development program at the South Australian Sports Institute.

[17] Neylan rode for Team Virtu Cycling during the 2019 season, during which time she won a stage at the Gracia–Orlová[18] and recorded two more Top 10 finishes in the WorldTour.

[10] At the end of 2019, Virtu Cycling closed the women's team and Neylan signed for new Spanish outfit Cronos–Casa Dorada.

However one of the major backers of the team pulled their funding, preventing Neylan from taking part in the races required for her to qualify for the 2020 Summer Olympics.