[2] Before joining the Sports Authority of India, an amateur football club, Rehenesh had participated in some age group tournaments in his home state.
[5] Rehenesh made his professional debut for ONGC in the I-League against Pailan Arrows on 1 December 2012 coming on as a 56th-minute substitute for Bimal Minz after number one goalkeeper Prosenjit Ghosh was red carded.
On 14 July 2013, Rehenesh joined newly formed Mumbai Tigers who were about to compete in I-League after coach Bimal Ghosh convinced him.
[13] Rehenesh joined NorthEast United FC on loan Shillong Lajong for 2014 Indian Super League season.
He made his debut for Lajong in opening game of 2014-15 I-League season in a 2–1 loss to newly promoted Royal Wahingdoh on 18 January 2015.
[22] In 2015 ISL, although NorthEast United missed the semi-final berth, TP Rehenesh emerged as a more skilled and prolific player, making total number of 47 saves, more than any other goalkeeper in the tournament and kept 4 cleansheets.
[25] Due to the arrival of former India International Subrata Paul, Rehenesh was demoted to the role of second choice keeper.
Due to Paul's injury, he managed to get starts in last two games of the season as NorthEast once again failed to qualify for playoffs as they finished fifth in league stage.
[29] He was adjudged with man of the match award in Kolkata Derby against Mohun Bagan which ended in a 0–0 stalemate on 12 February 2017.
[45] After the game, a teary-eyed TP Rehenesh apologetically stood in front of the Kerala Blasters supporters who were present at the Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium after a heavy defeat.
[52] He made his debut against Kerala Blasters FC on 3 November 2024, coming on as a 78th-minute substitute for Phurba Lachenpa, who had picked up an injury.
[53] Rehenesh made his full debut for Mumbai against Mohammedan SC, keeping a clean sheet in a routine 1–0 win for The Islanders.
[54] Rehenesh played again in the club's following match, at home against Chennaiyin FC, making four saves and keeping a clean sheet in a 1–0 win for Mumbai.