Reice attended Penn State University where he was a 1977 First Team All American soccer player.
[1][2] In 1978, the Philadelphia Fury selected Reice in the first round of the North American Soccer League draft.
The Stoners went to the ASL championship where they defeated the Sacramento Spirits 2–1 on goals by Reice and George Gorleku.
[4] In 1983, he joined the Wichita Wings of Major Indoor Soccer League.
[5] Reice then coached the Neshaminy High School boys' team, winning the 1995 Trenton, New Jersey high school coach of the year honors.