The mall's anchor stores are Cinemark Theatres, Dick's Sporting Goods, and JCPenney.

[2] Construction began in June 1986, by which point Glimcher had confirmed that the mall would consist of nearly 500,000 square feet (46,000 m2) of retail space, including approximately 80 shops and restaurants and a movie theater.

[13] Steve & Barry's, which took the former Ames in 2003, closed in 2009 when the chain went out of business, although the mall also added IHOP and Old Navy at this point.

A 2009 Columbus Dispatch article noted that the additions of these new stores countered concerns about decreasing mall traffic after the US 33 by pass of Lancaster was built in 2005.

[16] At the same time, Glimcher put up both River Valley and Indian Mound malls for sale.