He was the 2009 BCJALL Most Valuable Player leading the league with 107 points and was a First Team All-Star.

Church earned Rookie of the Week four times, as a result he was named to the NCAA's All-Rookie Team.

Church was named to the men's lacrosse program 75th Anniversary all-time team.

[9] In the same year, Church scored 23 power-play goals to lead the NLL for a second consecutive season.

[11] Church led the NLL in 2016 with 17 power-play goals and finished tied for 14th in league scoring with 86 points.