Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin

Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin is a large oil and tempera on oak panel painting, usually dated between 1435 and 1440, attributed to the Early Netherlandish painter Rogier van der Weyden.

Housed in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, it shows Luke the Evangelist, patron saint of artists, sketching the Virgin Mary as she nurses the Child Jesus.

The enclosed garden, illusionistic carvings of Adam and Eve on the arms of Mary's throne, and attributes of St Luke are amongst the painting's many iconographic symbols.

The figure's positioning and colourisation are reversed, and Luke takes centre stage; his face is accepted as van der Weyden's self-portrait.

By positioning himself in the same space as the Madonna, and showing a painter in the act of portrayal, Van der Weyden brings to the fore the role of artistic creativity in 15th-century society.

[10] The most obvious similarity is the two figures standing at a bridge, who may not carry specific identities;[11] those in the van der Weyden are sometimes identified as Joachim and Anne, the Virgin's parents.

Van der Weyden switches the colours of their costumes; Luke is dressed in red or scarlet, Mary in the more typical warm blues.

[2] The dominant pigments are lead white (often used in the panel to highlight blue and green passages), charcoal black, ultramarine, lead-tin-yellow, verdigris and red lake.

Mary has turned her face so that he can depict her in near full profile, a rare honour, while Luke's kneeling position is closely analogous to that of a typical donor portrait in the presence of the Virgin.

[25] Compared to contemporary paintings of this type, the work is unusually free of inscriptions; they appear only on items in Luke's study, dimly perceived on his right: on a book, on an ink bottle, and on a scroll emanating from the mouth of his ox, beneath the small desk.

[26] The scene is set within a rather narrow interior space,[27] with a barrel vault ceiling, patterned floor tilings, and stained glass windows.

[30] The figures seem preoccupied with "looking", which Carol Purtle believes, to van der Weyden, was a form of devotionalism; through meditating on an image, the "beholder experienced visions of transports of ecstasy".

[13] As in the van Eyck, the figures act as examples of repoussoir,[35] in that they draw our attention to the picture's underlying theme – the painting's ability to visualize the infinity of the world in the landscape.

This is reinforced by the fact that Luke is shown drawing in silverpoint on white paper; an extremely difficult medium that demands high concentration, and is normally used only for preparation.

[41] The artist is boldly emphasising his ability and skill with preparatory sketches; a single surviving silverpoint drawing attributed to van der Weyden, now in the Louvre, contains a female head very similar to Mary's in the Boston panel.

[45] What biographical details are available place the artist as a devout Catholic, deeply influenced by mystical and devotional texts, familiar with 12th and 13th century female theologians such as Mechthild of Magdeburg and Hildegard of Bingen.

[15] Smith describes the panel as an "exposition of the art of painting", observing that van der Weyden records the essential skills any successful artist should master while claiming to be an heir to St Luke.

[24] He works in silverpoint – and thus is unencumbered with the paraphernalia of painting; an easel, seat or other items which might clutter the composition, or more importantly place a physical barrier between the divine and earthly realms.

Van der Weyden presents Mary as the Maria Lactans virgin type, a symbol of "Mother Church" especially popular at times of plague or famine, the implication being that she cares for all and no one will go hungry.

[50] Van der Weyden had earlier portrayed Mary breast-feeding in his Virgin and Child Enthroned, which depicts equally detailed carvings carrying significance, but is reduced in size and in its cast of characters, and omits the act of beholding.

Van der Weyden omits the winged angel holding a crown hovering above the Virgin; the figure was included in the underdrawings, but eventually abandoned.

[25] Van der Weyden presents a humanised Virgin and Child, as suggested by the realistic contemporary surroundings,[53] the lack of halos, and the intimate spatial construction.

In the early 1930s, based on X-radiographs, art historian Alan Burroughs attributed the Boston painting to Dieric Bouts "under the supervision" of van der Weyden.

[56] The approach to the underdrawing is very similar to the paintings where attribution to van der Weyden is established, such as the Descent from the Cross in Madrid, and the Miraflores Altarpiece in Berlin.

[1] The painting is recorded in 1835 in the collection of Don Infante Sebastián Gabriel Borbón y Braganza, a grandnephew of Charles III of Spain and himself an artist.

The effort was led by the restorer Helmut Ruhemann, who described the panel as "structurally sound", and removed layers of discoloured varnish and "crude overpainting", while filling in some areas of paint loss.

Van der Weyden's interpretation was hugely influential during the mid-15th and early-16th centuries, both in free and faithful adaptations and copies,[37] examples of which are in Brussels, Kassel, Valladolid and Barcelona.

[66] Depictions of Luke drawing the Virgin rose in popularity in the mid-to-late 15th century, with van der Weyden's panel the earliest known from the Low Countries[67] – Campin's earlier treatment was by then lost.

[72] The similarities to the van der Weyden are many and striking, and include the painting utensils, red robes, physician's cap and blue mantle.

The figure has the same middle-aged facial type and his pose, kneeling on a green cushion, although reversed compared to van der Weyden's, is the same.

Detail of Saint Luke; probable van der Weyden self-portrait [ 4 ]
Copy after Rogier van der Weyden, Saint Luke drawing the Virgin (detail), c. 1491–1510 . Groeningemuseum , Bruges
Jan van Eyck, Madonna of Chancellor Rolin , c. 1435. Louvre , Paris
The folds in Mary's dress
Jan van Eyck, Madonna of Chancellor Rolin (detail)
Detail of figures in the midground
After van der Weyden, The Justice of Trajan and Herkinbald , detail from a lost painting, tapestry copy. This head is considered another probable self-portrait. [ 46 ]
Van der Weyden's small Virgin and Child Enthroned , c. 1430–1432. Museo Thyssen-Bornemisza
Carvings on the Virgin's throne
October 1914 photograph of the panel in its old frame. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston
Master of the Legend of St. Ursula , Virgin and Child , late 15th century
Hugo van der Goes , Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin , c. 1470–80. National Museum of Ancient Art , Lisbon