Unlike the other five singles from Lead Me On, "Say Once More" does not feature any explicitly Christian lyrics, though it performed well on Christian radio and can arguably be read either as a secular love song or as a love letter to God.
On September 9, 2014, a remix EP was released on iTunes in support of the album: Despite the small role of faith in the lyrics, "Say Once More" was a success on Christian radio, peaking at #2 on the Christian music charts in the United States.
The second disc of that re-release featured a new recording of "Say Once More" by Amy Grant with Will Owsley on guitar.
Grant described the new recording as "a songwriter's version", with the music stripped down to further emphasize the lyrics.
In promoting the re-release, Grant performed the new acoustic version during various media appearances.