[5][6] He played in 11 regular season games, making 21 of 29 field goal attempts and punting 70 times with a 41.7-yard average before the kicking duties were given back to McCallum in October that year.

[6] Whyte played in only two regular season games where he made all six of his field goal attempts and punted 15 times for a 40.1-yard average.

[7] He won the kicking job following training camp and connected on 45 of 52 field goal attempts and punted 115 times for a 41.3-yard average throughout all 18 regular season games in 2011.

[8] Whyte continued to play well for the Alouettes as he connected on 80.5% of his field goal attempts in 2012 and 82.0% in 2013, where he was named a Division All-Star for the first time in his career.

[5] He had his best season as an Alouette in 2014 when he made 41 of 47 field goal attempts for an 87.2% completion rate and had a career-high punting average of 44.9 yards.

[10][11] On September 4, 2015, it was announced that Whyte had signed with the Edmonton Eskimos, after the team's incumbent kicker, Grant Shaw had been injured.

[5] Despite making just one of his three field goal attempts, the Eskimos prevailed and defeated the Ottawa Redblacks by a score of 26–20 in the 103rd Grey Cup game and Whyte won his first championship.

On July 7, 2024, Whyte successfully kicked his 31st consecutive field goal, breaking the BC Lions franchise record previously held by Paul McCallum, and finished the game having made 32 in a row.