In 1988, Versyp was named All-Big Ten and CoSIDA All-American, and won honors as the school's women's athlete of the year.

After graduating from Purdue, Versyp became the head coach at Lawrence North High School in Indianapolis from 1989 to 1993, taking a 0–18 team to a sectional runner-up finish in two seasons.

After going 20–9,[4] sharing the Conference USA regular-season title and an earning NCAA berth, Childers left for James Madison University.

[4] In 2000,[5] Versyp became the head coach at Maine for five seasons, where she amassed a 98–51 record, including 67–19 in America East Conference.

Versyp coached 2003 and 2004 America East Player of the Year, Heather Ernest, who went on to play professionally overseas.

Versyp took the head coaching job at Indiana University in 2005–06,[6] where she led her team to a 19–14 season, 9–7 in the Big Ten and the quarterfinals of the post-season WNIT.

[10] The Journal & Courier reported on August 18, 2021, that Purdue University was investigating allegations that Versyp created a “toxic and hostile environment,” including verbally attacking players and bullying a member of her coaching staff.

[12] On October 26, 2022, Versyp announced she would return to coaching and begin building the University of South Carolina Beaufort's new women's basketball program.