When this team folded after five seasons, one of Currie's coaches Andy Keenan began hosting sessions for Year Five girls in Heeley.

Despite only five players attending the first training session, they entered a local youth league in 1998–99 as Sheffield United Community Girls.

Inspired by 75-goal striker Jodie Michalska, the club secured promotion to the Midland Combination Women's Football League in 2005–06.

[5] In December 2024, it was announced that COH Sports had completed the purchase of Blades Leisure Ltd., the company that owned the team.

[6] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.