Sarah Brehm, indicating in a four star review at HM wrote, "It's an album filled with indie rock music that would be just as comfortable in the church as it would in a coffee house.

"[3] Awarding the album four stars from Jesus Freak Hideout, Scott Fryberger states, "With Sing My Welcome Home, they've established themselves as one of the best worship bands of today.

"[5] Timothy Estabrooks, giving the album three and a half stars for Jesus Freak Hideout, writes, "overall, Sing My Welcome Home is an effective and creative re-introduction to some classic hymns that definitely deserves a few spins.

"[6] Rating the album four stars at Indie Vision Music, Scott Swan says, "Pacific Gold manages to not only re-energize lyrics from old, but also fosters a style that reawakens musical genres from bygone eras.

[1] Giving the album three stars for CM Addict, Jon Ownbey opines, "Sing My Welcome Home is a great album for those who enjoy the sounds of indie rock with lyrics that are spiritually focused.