The founding editors of the journal were Louis E. Newman and Jonathan K.
[2] The current editors of the journal are Jonathan K. Crane and Emily Filler.
[3] The editorial board has included Elliot N. Dorff, Robert B. Gibbs, Alyssa Gray, Martin Kavka, Jonathan Sacks, David Teutsch, Noam Zohar, Laurie Zoloth, Julia Watts Belser, Yonatan Brafman, Geoffrey Claussen, Aaron S. Gross, Jeffrey Israel, Michal Raucher, Danya Ruttenberg, Moses Pava, Suzanne Last Stone, and Jonathan Schofer.
The Society of Jewish Ethics board objected to Wright's claim that Israel was engaged in ethnic cleansing.
[12] Jewish theologian Marc Ellis criticized the Society of Jewish Ethics board for their objection to Wright's appearance and for their failure to criticize Israel during the 2009 Gaza War.