[3] In 1959, the congregation again changed locations, purchasing the Stonehenge Mansion on Ponce de Leon Avenue in Eastside, Atlanta.

The building is an example of Tudor period Gothic Revival architecture and was constructed with granite from Stone Mountain (which at the time was owned by Samuel and his brother William Venable).

A sanctuary was added in 1969 based on designs by architects Barker and Cunningham using granite from Stone Mountain.

[4] The octagonal shape, used in earlier periods of history to signify the "eighth day of creation" (baptism into the death and resurrection of Jesus), was contemporary in 1969.

The four-sided cross above the altar is made of faceted glass and a W. Zimmer & Sons pipe organ was added in 1983.