In January 1906, amid financial woes, the city was facing the prospect of selling of their land for which they intended to erect the new municipal building.

Ultimately a $7,953 ($269,695 adjusted for inflation) contract was granted to Youngferdorf & Son, who would be responsible for the building's foundation, outside and inside walls, roof, gas piping, and flooring.

The building's architect, W. W. Goodrich, explained in a letter to the council that the contract was not completed due to poor weather and failed shipments.

Eventually, Goodrich won the favor of Mayor Hinman, who called for the contact be restored to Youngfedorf & Son.

It was noted that there was a balance of $6019.10 ($181,286 adjusted for inflation) on the books just a week prior, prompting Portland officials to launch an investigation.

[9] In 1976, the building was temporarily closed for improvements which was a part of an urban renewal plan spearheaded by mayor Neil Goldschmidt.

[11] Plans to close the precinct were announced in 1994, but canceled at the urging of St. Johns residents and mayor Vera Katz.

[12] Budget cuts forecasted the need to close the building in 1997, but again mayor Katz led the effort to save the precinct which was ultimately successful.