The gained senior status after earning promotion into Division Two by finishing Runners-up in the League and Cup.

The club's two main sponsors, STAMCO and Croft Glass, were fused into the new name, the result was St. Leonards Stamcroft.

The 1996–97 season saw the club finish runners up to Forest Green and won the Sussex Senior Cup, beating Saltdean United 2–1 in the final.

During the summer of 1993, the ground was redeveloped ensuring the club could play in Division One of the Sussex County League.

Further improvements were made to the ground in 1996, to allow the club to enter the Southern League, after initially being rejected.