[1] It was demolished in 1868 and the church was rebuilt almost entirely in 1868–69 by George Edmund Street (1824–1881).

An illustration of the finished church was featured in The Building News on 5 January 1870.

The church's large North Chapel houses the tombs of Charles Hanbury-Tracy, 1st Baron Sudeley (1778–1858) and his wife Henrietta Susanna Tracy.

Lord Sudeley left £5000 towards the creation of the tombs, which were designed by John Graham Lough.

The large sums of money which the family donated towards the building an upkeep of the church, combined with the agricultural depression of the late 19th Century were eventually contributory factors to the financial decline of the Hanbury-Tracy family.