Building of the present church began on 4 June 1889, with the laying of the foundation stone by the Bishop of Guildford.
This was the result of a petition to the Bishop of Winchester from the merchants of St Aubin in which they made their case for the erection of a chapel of ease, in which they mentioned the difficulty of travelling to St Brelade, a distance of about two miles: "[T]he road to the said Church is very difficult by reason of many rugged steep ascents and descents, and a great way of moving sands, and the said inhabitants are exposed to great fatigue by sheer scorching heat in the summer, and the storms of impetuous westerly winds which usually blows there in Winter …" The original church was a square building which stood on the site of the present church car park.
A meeting was held on 19 April 1889, and it was resolved that a committee be formed to collect funds and arrange the building of a new church.
At the north end of the nave, the altar which bears the logo of the St Brelade Group of Churches, and the platform on which it stands, were added in the 1980s under the curacy of Robert Booth.
In the early part of 1992 further re-ordering saw the removal of a number of pews and the construction of a platform around the font at the south end.