Saints won the Syd Roberts, Reg Lawrence and Graham Edwards Memorial Trophies often defeating teams from higher leagues.

Saints only waited a year to return to the Gay Meadow, this time to lift the Shropshire Junior Cup defeating Bishops Castle through a 3–1 victory.

Saints also added another Graham Edwards Trophy, but following the resignation of Andrew Roberts, the club found it hard to cope in Shropshire's top division.

Saints, under the guidance of Derek Stokes dropped down in the Shropshire Alliance League to rebuild.

Benji Evans stepped in to steady the ship, Saints earned respectable league campaigns with top half finishes over a two-year period.

This partnership was a successfully recipe with Evans developing youth players and Rogers was able to build a first team that could mount a genuine push for promotion.

St Martins FC progressed to step 6 football after being accepted into the North West Counties Division One South for the 2018–19 season, joining other local teams Oswestry Town and Ellesmere Rangers in making the move to North West Football.

In 2022/2023 Liam Braisdell formally took the reins as First-Team Manager and the majority of the reserve team were retained for a new season at Step 7.