Bible Christians arrived in the islands and began preaching from the Bishop and Wolf Inn.

The first chapel was built on Church Street in Hugh Town around 1836 (and is now used as the Masonic Hall).

The current chapel was built at a cost of around £1,300 (equivalent to £184,800 in 2023)[1] between 1899 and 1900 to the designs of the architect A. J. Trenear.

The chapel was built to seat 350 people, 198 on the ground floor and 152 in the gallery.

George Woodcock of Church Street, St Mary's, laid the principal foundation stone.