The mall was eventually closed in 2008 and was ultimately demolished in 2011 to make way for a mixed-use development featuring a Kroger Marketplace.

[2] Not only that, but nearby Chesterfield Towne Center just underwent a major renovation, and development was expanding west, away from Cloverleaf.

In 2000, JCPenney closed their Cloverleaf store and moved to Chesterfield Towne Center, followed in 2003 by Sears and Hecht's, which replaced Thalhimers.

In 2005, a local church wanted to buy the mall to turn it into a multi-purpose facility, with one of the former anchors becoming a sanctuary with about 5,000 seats.

The mall, along with all outparcels (except for a Firestone auto care center and a now closed Bank of America branch) were demolished in 2011 to make way for Stonebridge, a mixed-use development featuring the first Virginian Kroger Marketplace along with many other commercial tenants, and apartments.