After Reid Genauer's departure, Strangefolk underwent lineup changes and auditions, eventually inviting Luke "Patchen" Montgomery to join the band, along with keyboardist Scott Shdeed.
In early 2005, while Jon Trafton underwent cancer treatment, the remaining members formed a side project called The Windfalls with guitarist Steve Jones of the band The Boneheads.
The band faced Trafton's cancer diagnosis with overwhelming support and solidarity from family, friends, bandmates, and fans.
On January 10, 2012, Strangefolk announced a pair of reunion shows with the original lineup, featuring Reid Genauer, Jon Trafton, Erik Glockler, and Luke Smith.
The title track featured all four original members of Strangefolk on a studio album for the first time since Genauer initially left the band in 2000.
The organization continues to work with numerous bands across the United States, striving to make a positive difference by addressing hunger issues one concert at a time.
Despite the band's evolution, lineup changes, and individual pursuits, Strangefolk's unique sound and contributions to the music scene, particularly in Vermont, have left a lasting legacy.
Their performances and reunion shows have been celebrated by fans, and their music continues to resonate with audiences who appreciate their blend of acoustic, folk, and rock elements.