[2] It became one of the top five best-selling college guidebooks[3] and was turned into a series, released in five annually updated editions.

[6] Goldman and Buyers edited the results into a 704-page college guide profiling schools across America and including some explicit content.

They were signed by the literary agency Janklow & Nesbit Associates and their manuscript was purchased by Penguin Books, the second largest publisher in the world.

[7] Chuck Hughes, Senior Admissions Officer at Harvard, signed on to write the book’s preface, calling it the result of “a virtual grassroots movement … spurred on by the power of the Internet and the power of student networks ... friends told friends about Students’ Guide ... news spread from school to school.” Hughes described the finished product as “a new kind of guidebook … providing detailed, nuanced, personal and honest portraits of schools … the stories behind the statistics ... the next best thing to spending a week on campus.”[8] After its initial publication Goldman, Buyers and Penguin Books turned Students' Guide into a series, released in five annually updated editions.

Goldman and Buyers launched new online surveys and edited tens of thousands of new student submissions for publication each year.