It is hosted by View Askew Productions regulars and close friends of Kevin Smith: Bryan Johnson and Walt Flanagan of AMC's Comic Book Men, as well as Brian Quinn of Impractical Jokers.

was recorded at Jay and Silent Bob's Secret Stash in Red Bank, New Jersey, the location seen in the television show Comic Book Men, and the A Shared Universe PodcaStudio, run by Ming Chen and Mike Zapcic.

The show's title comes from a running joke in Smith's View Askewniverse movies in which Flanagan's character, Fanboy, yells "Tell 'em, Steve-Dave!"

[8] Gitem began working at the stash in 2016 and started to help Walt Flanagan to create games for the podcast.

Ming early on upset Walt and in an act of revenge Walt created a listener contest called the "Not So Superbowl",[12] in which Ming was made to judge dozens of listener submitted pictures of feces covered toilet bowls.

[10] He made it to the finals of the Blue Juice Comics One True Three Invitational against his podcast partner Ming Chen.

Dave has appeared throughout the history of the show, detailing stories of his life as a rocker and thoughts on comics, music, and the state of pop culture.